Skip to main content

Complacency Leads to Chaos and Confusion in "V for Vendetta"

By Tinkerbell03

           The main themes and arguments of “V for Vendetta” can be seen whether discussing the movie or graphic novel. Themes such as freedom, government control, and anarchy are just a few ideas addressed in this work. However, the medium in which these ideas are delivered makes an important impact on how the audience perceives them. For example, although both the graphic novel and movie version of V for Vendetta have similar themes, an audience that has only seen the movie, might feel differently about what they experienced compared to an audience that is only familiar with the graphic novel. This is because of the differences in how the message is being delivered. 

Comics and graphic novels require much more participation from their audience than film does. This phenomenon is what Scott McCloud refers to as “closure” in his book Understanding Comics. In between each frame of a comic, there is a small gap before another image appears. Comics are not all one large picture nor do they have the ability to play continuously like a movie does. The audience is only seeing pieces and fragments of a situation with a blank space in between. It is in this “gutter” that the audience becomes pivotal in making closure take place (McCloud 63).  Closure in comics is what helps move the story along and allows for many changes to take place that would normally be happening quite naturally and smoothly in a movie. Transitions such as time, motion, and scene are just a few of the shifts that are a direct result of closure in comics (McCloud 65). Audience involvement is what allows these transformations to occur, and without them, the message can be misconstrued or completely misunderstood. Due to the very nature of a graphic novel, the audience must not be too complacent or uninvolved, otherwise they could miss out on some very important ideas and happenings. This is exactly the kind of message that the character of “V” is trying to deliver to the citizens of London in the graphic novel V for Vendetta. This can be seen throughout the graphic novel, but specifically the scene were “V” interferes and intercepts the television stations across England. In this scenario, “V” calls out England’s citizens for just standing by and letting their government turn into the suffocating authoritarian system that it is currently ruled under. “V” declares that it is not only the leaders that are to blame, but the contented citizens who elected them in the first place that are at fault as well (Moore 112-118).  It is appropriate then, to deliver this kind of message in a medium that requires its own audience to be active participants in order to understand the intent and outcome of V for Vendetta. Just as the citizens of England will need to be dynamic contributors to making a change in their government, so will the readers of this graphic novel to make changes and create closure to comprehend its message. One can see the chaos and confusion that was a result of complacent citizens in V for Vendetta. A similar outcome will be the consequence of a complacent reader. Thus, the medium is the message as Scott McCloud can confirm.  

McCloud, Scott, and Mark Martin. Understanding Comics: the Invisible Art. William Morrow, HarperCollinsPublishers, 2018.

Moore, Alan, and David Lloyd. V For Vendetta. DC Comics, 2012.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Analysis of Aya: Life in Yop City

By
To begin this week's post, I'd like to first address a few things about the author's duty to his/her readers. When we think of reading material from other countries or cultures, what factors are important to us? What information do we need in order to recognize the significance of the author's work? For me, it's important for the author to find some way to connect to me as a reader. Do we share a common experience? Can I relate your story to mine? This is not to say that a writer's work is rendered unimpressive if they choose not to do this. But I do think it goes without saying that most impressionable works hit us emotionally. I also think that an author should be conscious of the world that they are painting for the reader. Is it true what you're writing? Does it provide some sort of insight into the world as you see it? Are you confirming outside opinions of your culture, or are you breaking the stereotypes that have been placed upon you? That being sai...
Post a Comment
Read more

Junji Ito and the Art of the Uncanny

By
As discussed in Chapter 2 of Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics , the Japanese style of comic book art holds several notable quirks. While early manga artists tended to favor simplistic, yet distinct styles that paved the way for a number of internationally renowned characters, contemporary manga artists have since favored a hybrid style that juxtaposes the cutesy, rounded characters of yesteryear with the realistic and richly shaded settings that have since become popular. Building on this, McCloud describes a phenomenon in which Japanese comic artists have used realism to objectify--that is, to emphasize the "otherness" of certain characters, objects, or places--elements of their work and further separate these elements from the reader. I have chosen the work of one of my favorite comic artists, Japanese horror icon Junji Ito, to further illustrate McCloud's point. Though McCloud describes this phenomenon in the context of Japanese comic book art, he is usi...
1 comment
Read more

Bringing Africa into the Fold

By
The comic Aya: Life in Yop City does a fantastic job of illustrating a culture different from the more popular Western variety. For those reading this, have you ever considered Africa in any way that was not influenced by main stream media? No? Well me either. It is sad to say, but my view of Africa was just - more or less - a vast land of chaos and poverty. Why? Because is that not what the media would have us believe? As a western country ourselves - presuming, of course, that you are reading this from the US or some European country - we do not consider other nations to have much value in comparison to our own. Because we have created a Eurocentric view of what society should be, we have disallowed other countries to feel that their own culture is worth portraying in novels or media. For example, most people are lead to believe that Africa is riddled with disease, famine, and "uneducated" people who are in dire need of help. This just isn't true! There are places ...
Post a Comment
Read more