Skip to main content

What are we fighting for?

By Anonymous
Do you remember where you were on September 11, 2001? If you ask someone this question, and they are over a certain age they can rattle off to you where they were, what they were doing and how old they were. For example, I was 11 years old and in my 6th grade orchestra class when the World Trade Center was attacked. Did I know or understand what was going on? Not really, but not many people did

Satrapi, Marjane. Persepolis. Paris, France, 2003.

I was around the same age as the author of Persepolis when 9/11 happened. This graphic novel focuses around the author of the graphic novel Marjane Satrapi and her family during the Islamic Revolution. Marji’s actions and feelings early on in the novel concerning the revolution really struck me as familiar. She thought she understood what was happening, and wanted to be apart of the demonstrations, but at the same time she didn’t know the whole situation. How her parents explained things to her was also familiar, since after 9/11 I myself had lots of questions about what was going on because I didn’t understand what was happening. It was familiar because my parents were like Marji’s parents where they didn’t want to lie to us about what was happening in the country at the time, but they also didn’t want to scare us. In Marji’s case since the revolution was so violent and could not be easily explained to a 10-year-old they had to walk a very fine line when it came down to what they did and didn’t share. 


To borrow an idea from another class I’m taking, just because something was written in another country or another time period that doesn’t mean that you can’t find similarities somewhere. Cultures may be different, but the way that people respond emotionally usually doesn’t. This was something I had to remind myself of though, especially when reading the part about Marji’s mother being photographed during one of the demonstrations and then having to hide her face when it was printed in an Iranian magazine. In America if someone had been photographed at a demonstration it would be all over the media, and social media if it is 2019. In our culture that woman would have been hailed and exalted for standing up for what she believed in (by most people, because there is always one) but that is American culture. In Iranian culture the women didn’t and don’t have those type of rights.

If someone feels passionately enough about something, they’re going to want to fight for what they believe in. Sometimes the question needs to be asked though what are you fighting for or against? Satrapi shows this to readers in Persepolis and also shows how different cultures deal with hardships, these hardships are dealt with in similar and different ways. As I said, cultures may be different, but people’s emotional response is usually pretty similar.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Iconic Abstraction and the Vocabulary of Comics in Hellboy

By Anonymous
In Chapter 2 of Understanding Comics , McCloud talks about two key concepts I’d like to discuss: he identifies reality , language , and the picture plane as a representation of the pictorial vocabulary of comics, and he expresses a scale for iconic abstraction of comic art. As readers following the action in comics, we are guided by what objects and events cartoonists decide demand focus in each individual moment or panel. This focus via simplification of reality - referred to as abstraction - provides a rhythm of reading the visual representation of a sequence of events, controlling the timing of action and dialogue through spacing of panels and objects on a page. McCloud makes it clear that abstraction in comics is really just about the representation of ideas . Conceptually, we can perceive a specific drawn event, such as an explosion or a fight, without that event being pictured exactly or photorealistically. Rubble or glass flying midair can represent the impact of fights depi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Maus a Non-Fiction Graphic Novel?

By
Art Spiegelman’s Maus is considered to be a non-fiction graphic novel, but is creating a graphic novel based off a true story even allowed? Maybe you thought graphic novels were meant to be fiction. Well, I think the form of a graphic novel should not be restricted to only fiction. It is known for graphic novels to be fiction rather than non-fiction because that is what a novel is, fiction, but the name shouldn’t be a limitation of what can and cannot be told though this medium. There are many reasons for why telling a non-fiction story through the form of a graphic novel is beneficial. Spiegelman was able to share the story of his father’s holocaust experience by creating a graphic novel of it, and from the looks of it, it’s been very successful. Telling a story through the form of a graphic novel allows the creator to deliver it in a unique way. We are able to understand the plot because of the language that is used along with the accompanying panels. In Maus , Spiegelman writes e...
Post a Comment
Read more

Walking Through Fire: "Sita's Ramayana"

By Anonymous
Ramayana stands among India's oldest epic poems, one of the two surviving stories dating as far back as the seventh century B.C. Unfortunately, its protagonist has not stood the test of time. The poem tells the story of Rama, an exiled prince whose wife, Sita, chooses to accompany him despite not facing the same punishment. When Sita is kidnapped, Rama rescues her more out of a sense of obligation than love, ultimately questioning his wife's virtue and casting her away through no fault of her own. Rama is upheld as the ideal man, husband, and king throughout his tale. Samhita Arni, the author of Sita's Ramayana , clearly thinks otherwise. Sita's Ramayana , as one might suspect, is a graphic novel retelling of the epic poem shared from Sita's point of view. The original poem leaves little room for the exploration of her character, treating her more as a blank slate meant to represent the ideal wife of the time. She merely exists to shape her husband's characte...
Post a Comment
Read more