Skip to main content

we get it, going vegan will not save the planet. (so is anybody going to tell us what will?)

By Anonymous
Earlier this year, Billie Eilish told her followers to “be smarter” and go vegan after sharing a graphic video of what is pretty much industry standard. She’s been an open advocate for veganism, but many still debate the individual consumer’s impact on the animal product industry.

I’m vegan, which I don’t tell people often because I live in Texas and I honestly don’t care if other people are or aren’t vegan or vegetarian at all. I wasn’t always vegan, but people do not enjoy stories of my goat-slaughtering youth.

We often hear the statistic that the meat industry is the biggest contributor to climate change, so capitalists can put the blame on individuals instead of industry. It still gets tossed around in young adult spaces.

I’m going to assume for now that young adults are the primary audience for any kind of activist-encouragement, which is what As the World Burns, a satirical graphic novel about climate change… tries to do?



I want to start off by saying I don’t actually recommend this book, and it was a struggle to identify the audience for it. I don’t like Derrick Jensen, well-known as a transmisogynist (I decided not to subject you to his hateful rhetoric, please don’t seek it out if it will upset you). McMillan may be alright.

Putting aside logical issues that makes this seem more like propaganda than a factual yet inspirational text (to someone who actually agrees, which is.. just.. how??? How do you even do that?), I categorized the audience as preteens-to-young adults who aren’t already activists. Just chillin' in the library.

Let’s be totally transparent about this, though. This book was published in 2007. It’s 2019. Excluding climate change deniers (who clearly aren’t going to do anything to help, including even at the individual level 🙄), we already know that we’re running out of time.

I don’t know a world pre-global warming - media has made jokes about the earth dying since I can remember. Teens already organize worldwide to protest climate change. It’s hard to imagine this book helps anyone but kids who might not even get the chance to act.

So... let’s just try to talk about what works...?


Shoving your idea in someone’s face is not a good way to get them to agree with you, which is why subtlety is key for political comics or cartoons.

But we know that is not the intent of this satirical tell-not-show comic, which I think would work well to speak to 13 year olds on the fence. Be direct with them, and they’ll understand - Haha, dumb hippies, telling foxes to go vegan! LOL the cute bunnies are labelled terrorists! Good old Axe-odored humour and unwittingly niche complaints.

Showing video of vivisections or animal torture is too unpleasant, but with cutesy pictures we get to further ourselves from reality, so it's not a real animal that has to suffer to get the point across! Lucky us! (Don’t mention that somehow the book manages to keep you in comfortable denial of reality while still arguing against it! Oh darn! I mentioned it!)

I guess the primary benefit to comics is that as an art form it’s almost limitless in what it can represent and how. All art forms and even word forms can be used in graphic novels to build worlds that do and do not exist, repeatedly. 

This book is similar to social activist zines in how it communicates the message with both crude and cutesy depictions of talking animals and violence and serious or alarming topics without being a boring infographic with citations*. Its real strength is probably in the exaggeration of both the message and how it's written.

Using a story is an ideal way to get the message across, and so this easily be an infographic if it was purely for educational use instead of also being hyperbolic for entertainment, which perhaps it does too much.

I guess, ultimately, I have to say that everywhere this book could succeed - like with its multiple narratives and viewpoints, visuals and text that don't match in tone to create a different form of satire, ability to capture emotions and actions that are technically impossible - it manages to fail completely, in a bizarrely contradictory way.

That’s not to say graphic novels aren’t great at encouraging advocacy and change. I think As the World Burns is just a bad example of it.

*data and infographics are not boring to me. sincerely, a data lover

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Maus a Non-Fiction Graphic Novel?

By
Art Spiegelman’s Maus is considered to be a non-fiction graphic novel, but is creating a graphic novel based off a true story even allowed? Maybe you thought graphic novels were meant to be fiction. Well, I think the form of a graphic novel should not be restricted to only fiction. It is known for graphic novels to be fiction rather than non-fiction because that is what a novel is, fiction, but the name shouldn’t be a limitation of what can and cannot be told though this medium. There are many reasons for why telling a non-fiction story through the form of a graphic novel is beneficial. Spiegelman was able to share the story of his father’s holocaust experience by creating a graphic novel of it, and from the looks of it, it’s been very successful. Telling a story through the form of a graphic novel allows the creator to deliver it in a unique way. We are able to understand the plot because of the language that is used along with the accompanying panels. In Maus , Spiegelman writes e...
Post a Comment
Read more

Walking Through Fire: "Sita's Ramayana"

By Anonymous
Ramayana stands among India's oldest epic poems, one of the two surviving stories dating as far back as the seventh century B.C. Unfortunately, its protagonist has not stood the test of time. The poem tells the story of Rama, an exiled prince whose wife, Sita, chooses to accompany him despite not facing the same punishment. When Sita is kidnapped, Rama rescues her more out of a sense of obligation than love, ultimately questioning his wife's virtue and casting her away through no fault of her own. Rama is upheld as the ideal man, husband, and king throughout his tale. Samhita Arni, the author of Sita's Ramayana , clearly thinks otherwise. Sita's Ramayana , as one might suspect, is a graphic novel retelling of the epic poem shared from Sita's point of view. The original poem leaves little room for the exploration of her character, treating her more as a blank slate meant to represent the ideal wife of the time. She merely exists to shape her husband's characte...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Two Faces of Anarchy in V for Vendetta

By Anonymous
As someone who has only seen the movie version of V for Vendetta once many years ago and have never read the graphic novel, I wasn’t exactly sure how similar or different the movie version would be to the graphic novel. I was in for a surprise when I discovered just how vastly different, they are from each other. With that being said, they do have some similarities when strictly looking at the motives of the characters. Let’s dive into those motives and how the author and illustrator of V for Vendetta achieved getting these motives across to their readers. In Scott McCloud’s chapter of Understanding Comics “ Blood in the Gutter ” we are presented with different panel – to – panel transitions, and an introduction to the term “gutter” as being the white space between the panels which is where the audience of reader “takes two separate images and transforms them into a single idea” (McCloud, 66). After finishing reading V for Vendetta , several themes or ideas that were most prevalent...
Post a Comment
Read more